The Ethical Challenges of Working With Older Adults

Marie Jones is a 73-year-old woman who lost hertherapy Itself. Once you have decided you have the
husband last year after almost 50 years of marriage.skills to treat Mrs. Jones, she must be fully informed
Her complaints are memory problems, poor appetite,about the process of therapy, including your
and low energy. Mrs. Jones told her physician that hertherapeutic style, fees and billing practices,
children think she should move into a retirementconfidentiality, and the risks and benefits of treatment.
community, but she is hesitant to give up her home. IfShe may need additional information about potential
Mrs. Jones or someone like her was referred to yourrecommendations such as psychological testing,
practice, would you be prepared to treat her? If youbereavement groups, or a medication consultation.
are like many other providers in the helping community,Once Mrs. Jones is given the information she needs to
the answer is most likely no. As the 20th centuryunderstand your work with her, she will then be better
draws to a close American society is graying. Lifeprepared to give informed content. If you have any
expectancies have increased dramatically during thedoubts about her competence to give consent, further
past 75 years, and the number of community dewevaluation will be needed before you begin treating
willing seniors is steadily rising. The stressful associatedMrs. Jones. This is Important for the provision of
with aging, such as environmental changes, retirement,ethically sound therapy and for the clients own safety.
loss of partners, and coping with Illnesses are all issuesIf Mrs. Jones does not appear to understand the
that could be addressed in psychotherapy. Yet verytherapeutic contract, she may have problems outside
few graduate programs offer training opportunities inthe therapy room that need to be quickly addressed.
clinical gerontology.Memory loss or decreases in functioning do not equal
Even when training is available, ageism may lead someincompetence, but they can serve as red flags for a
therapists to assume that emotional growth andcomprehensive assessment.
change among seniors is limited, and therefore not*Release of Information*
worth professional pursuit. Counter transference, oftenYou have been meeting with Mrs. Jones for about
based on personal fears of aging or family issues withtwo months when her son comes to visit from
parents/grandparents, can also pull people away fromanother state. He is very impressed with the
treating seniors. Whether the reasons are personal orImprovements he sees in his mother's mood and
professional, treating older adults when you are I'llself-care but continues to wonder whether his mother
prepared leaves the door wide open for ethicalshould move into a care facility. He also believes that
dilemmas and potential malpractice.some of his mother's problems relate to the physical
*Before the Work Begins*abuse she endured during most of her married life. He
Psychotherapy is an intensive exploration of personalcalls and leaves you this information and asks that you
values. Understanding your own value system andreturn his call without telling his mother he has been in
how it Impacts your work is the cornerstone of ethicaltouch. This phone message presents many problems
practice. Your beliefs drive the counseling processfor you. First, Mrs. Jones has yet to mention that her
forward, even in the most non directive of therapies.husband was abusive. She has presented her
As Christians, it is easy to underestimate themarriage as happy and stable. Second, Mrs. Jones
Importance of values clarification. Loving God, lovingdecided not to sign releases of information for her
our neighbors as ourselves, and believing in the healingchildren, because they worry enough about me and
power of Christ are all values that would appear to bethis would just make it worse. Her son learned about
self-evident within the Christian counseling community.her therapy from the family physician, who reported to
But there is tremendous diversity within the Body ofthe son that Mrs. Jones memory problems and
Christ as we will as many different understandings ofdepression seemed to be decreasing. When faced
health, healing, pathology, and change.with this turn of events, you must remain focused on
Assessing and articulating your values in the field ofyour client. You do not have access to Mrs. Jones son,
gerontology will involve prayerfully considering difficultas much as he would like to be helpful. In addition, you
questions. For example, what are your beliefsnow have Important therapeutic information that must
regarding the ending of life? If your client wanted to diebe sensitively addressed with your client. Honesty
by stopping painful medical treatment, how would youwithin the therapy demands that you let her know
decide what to do? Would your decision be different ifwhat has happened and work with her to reach a plan
your client was 65 or 85? Would your behavior placeof action.
you in conflict with accepted community standards of*Limits of Confidentiality*
practice or with state regulations and laws? ValuesWhen told about her sons call, Mrs. Jones states that
guide us, and they guide our clients. Once you haveher husband had been an active alcoholic for most of
taken the time to identify your values about the agingtheir marriage. During that time, he was physically
process and about older persons, you will be betterabusive. His eventual failing health led to his sobriety,
able to see how thesis will Impact your work. Beingand they spent the last 10 years of their lives together
aware, being clear, and being open respects both thein a peaceful and relatively happy relationship. Mrs.
process of therapy and the individual client. It also helpsJones also reveals that her youngest son, who lives
you steer clear of many ethics-related pitfalls.next door, is also an alcoholic and sometimes
*Common Ethical Dilemmas in Gerontology*becomes so angry that he hIt's her. An essential
Mrs. Jones has now been referred for counseling byaspect of ethically sound gerontological practice is
her family physician. He is concerned about herhaving a thorough understanding of elder abuse. It is
memory problems and wants a second opinion. Hepossible that some of the depression and cognitive
also thinks that Mrs. Jones is isolated and could benefitproblems observed in Mrs. Jones could be attributed to
from talking to someone about the relatively recentthe abuse she has been experiencing. The shame
loss of her spouse. Are you the appropriate referral?associated with being abused by their children leads
Even with the limited information we have about Mrs.many adults to keep the violence hidden, but the stress
Jones, there are many clues that can direct her mentaland trauma are often exhibited indirectly. It is your
health treatment. Her complaints may indicate theresponsibility to know the laws in your state regarding
onset of a dementia, but they can also suggest otherthe limits of confidentiality and the reporting
problems, such as depression, uncomplicatedrequirements for suspected elder abuse. This
bereavement, failing health, or even elder abuse.information should be shared with your clients when
Psychological assessment, individual therapy, and familytreatment begins, so they have the power to decide
therapy may all be appropriate parts of her treatmentwhen and how to share this information with you.
plan. As a provider, you must first evaluate your ownOnline Christian Counseling is a nice way to get
level of training and expertise. Just as you would notsuggestions.
think of treating children without adequate training, the*In Closing*
same standard applies to gerontological practice. If youThe best way to avoid ethical problems in
feel that you are under trained, you will need to accesspsychotherapy with any population is antecedent
old_resources such as supervision, continuingcontrol. Recognizing the limits of your training,
education, and consultation to assist your work. Theparticipating in continuing education, making sure you
most ethical decision may be to refer this client to ahave safety nets in place to assist your practice, and
colleague and take the time you need to develop yourstaying in touch with colleagues are all Important
skills.safeguards against ethical violations. As Christian
*Consent to Treatment*therapists, we have made a commitment to be Gods
Many older adults are unfamiliar with the process,instruments of healing in a broken world. This demands
demands, and expectations of psychotherapy.not only that we practice with the highest ethical
Although the senior community is rapidly becomingstandards of our profession, but that we constantly
more psychologically sophisticated, there are manyremain open to the work that God can do through us.
older persons who believe that counseling is only forKnowledgeable, we will-trained, and self-aware
really crazy people. They may be more comfortableclinicians who know their values, strengths, and limits
with a traditional doctor/ patient relationship and mayare going to be best equipped to meet this higher
not know what to expect from a therapist or fromstandard of care.